Three years ago, Iran agreed to inspections and limitations regarding its nuclear program under a
pact with the United States, Russia, China, Britain and Germany. These nations in turn agreed to
remove restrictions on Iranian oil sales among other economic activities, including foreign investment
opportunities. Under the agreement brokered by the Obama Administration, economic sanctions were
lifted, and Iran's oil sales and imports of nonagricultural products
skyrocketed. 1 2
As part of that deal, the United States waived certain restrictions allowing American companies to
conduct business directly through the Central Bank of Iran.
Today Iran, and countries who do business with the US and Iran, including the signatories of the
2015 Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, are concerned about the expiration
of the waiver this coming weekend. The Washington Post continued:
The price of West Texas Intermediate crude topped $70 a barrel Monday for the first time since
2014 amid fears that renewed U.S. sanctions would require international companies to buy less
Iranian oil or face stiff penalties.
According to October, 2017 BBC reporting, The Trump Administration asserts that Iran
broke parts of the agreement, including heavy-water limits and access to international inspectors,
and called for Congress to renegotiate the deal Mr. Trump considered too lenient. Current reporting
from The New York Times characterized those violations as "minor infractions that were
quickly rectified." 3
The Times article also stated that senior officials from Britain, France and
Germany had all traveled to Washington recently to try to convince the Trump Administration
to keep the nuclear deal, though flawed, in place. Particularly President Macron of France
and Chancellor Angela Merkel of Germany "suggested the West could impose new sanctions
against Iran's ballistic missile development and armed support for the Syrian regime" among others, rather than discard
the deal in its entirety. The same reporting cited an unidentified senior European diplomat
who told reporters today that it was "pretty obvious" Mr. Trump would not continue to waive
the sanctions.
Political commentary suggests that the US is being encouraged by regional allies to abandon
the deal with Iran simply because it's a deal with Iran an accord that could lead
to closer ties between Washington and Tehran that the Saudis cannot abide.4
Iranian oil exports are estimated to be about 2.6 million barrels per day. Renewed sanctions
could cut as much as 20% of those sales within months sales which account for over 60 percent
of Iran's total export revenue. The same reporting from The Washington Post claimed the
Trump Administration would begin asking oil traders to cut their consumption of Iranian crude,
and could levy penalties on those countries who do not comply.
Comment
The Times article quoted President Macron as saying he believed President Trump
would "get rid of this deal on his own, for domestic reasons." I can think of three:
- Trump First: The 2015 deal was orchestrated by the Obama Administration, and President
Trump can't let that stand despite the pleas of our European allies. He is driven to make
a deal that's bigger and better and bears the Trump name;
- America First: reducing the ready global supply of crude oil to make American oil more
attractive to the market (partly through coercion);
- To punish Iran for its role in the Syrian Civil War.
In 2017, US oil exports were almost double what they were in 2016, due to "booming
U.S. production, expanding pipeline and export capacity, and the more than $3-a-barrel
discount" 5. The surge has received the
attention of Asian markets previously devoted to OPEC:
U.S. crude oil exports to China accounted for 202,000 bpd—or 20 percent—of the 527,000-bpd
total increase in American exports in 2017, EIA data showed. . . . Another large Asian
crude oil importer, India, which had not received any U.S. oil in 2016, bought 22,000 bpd
in 2017 to tie with Spain as the tenth-largest destination of American crude sales.
"U.S. crude oil exports rose to 2.175 million
barrels per day, or more than 15 million a week, at the end of March," according to
CNBC reporting in early April.
Analysts expect the US to become the fourth largest oil exporter by 2022,
behind Saudi Arabia, Russia, and Iraq.
It doesn't seem much of a stretch that the Trump Administration would use an
available excuse to back the US out of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action
to further the US' ambitions as a major OPEC competitor. But there's no guarantee
the US will be able to strike the bigger, better deal President Trump is after,
and certainly the other signatories are concerned about the impact backing out
could have on their national interests.
For fairly easily digestible information about the Iran Nuclear Deal, see this simple guide published by The New
York Times.